Environmental DNA reveals secret reef inhabitants

Date:
April 21, 2022
Source:
ETH Zurich
Summary:
An international research team samples seawater from around the
world to reveal which tropical reef fish occur where. To identify
species and families, they successfully used the residual DNA shed
by the animals present in the water. But not all fish can be traced
in this way.



FULL STORY ==========================================================================
An international research team samples seawater from around the world
to reveal which tropical reef fish occur where. To identify species and families, they successfully used the residual DNA shed by the animals
present in the water.

But not all fish can be traced in this way.


========================================================================== Tropical coral reefs are colourful, beautiful -- and rich in species. The diversity among fish is particularly high: researchers estimate that
coral reefs are home to as many as 8,000 species of fish worldwide.

However, global warming and human activities are causing coral reefs to disappear at an alarming rate, and how many species of reef fish there
are and where they are distributed has not yet been accurately quantified.

One reason is that many fish species lead very secretive lives,
are very similar to each other or live partly in the open sea and are
therefore difficult to detect. To record the presence of fish in an area, biodiversity research has mostly depended on visual observations by divers
(or catching fish).

Now, a new method is making its way into ecology that circumvents such difficulties: environmental DNA (eDNA). The idea of this new approach
is that organisms leave their genetic material or parts of it in the environment.

With this approach, the researchers have only to take water samples at
one location, isolate the DNA (fragments) contained therein and sequence
them, i.e.

determine the order of DNA building blocks. Then they can compare the
sequences with reference DNA sequences that come from reliably identified specimens - - and can determine whether a species occurs at the location
in question.



==========================================================================
This is the method used by an international team led by researchers
from the University of Montpellier (France) and ETH Zurich to study the occurrence of reef fish.

In 2017 and 2019, the researchers collected 226 water samples at 26
sites in 5 tropical marine regions. They isolated and analysed the DNA,
which they then assigned to the corresponding species or families.

One-sixth greater diversity detected Using eDNA, the researchers found
a 16 percent higher diversity of reef fishes than through conventional
survey methods such as visual observations during dives. "Thanks to the
eDNA method, we can detect many fish species and families much faster
than with observations alone," says Loi"c Pellissier, Professor of
Ecosystems and Landscape Evolution at ETH Zurich. He is one of the two
lead authors of a study that has just been published in the scientific
journal Proceedings of the Royal Society. The DNA analyses were completed
after only two years, but the visual observations that informed the study
came from countless observers and cover 13 years of observation activity.

With the new approach, the researchers discovered more species swimming
in the open water (pelagic), reef-bound species, and species that inhabit
the numerous caves and crevices in reefs (cryptobenthic). Divers see or identify such fish with less frequency.



==========================================================================
Many of the recorded pelagic species prefer the open sea or greater
depths.

Some belong to families that avoid divers or do not live permanently
in coral reefs, such as mackerel and tuna in the family Scombridae as
well as sharks from the family Carcharhinidae (requiem sharks, e.g. the blacktip reef shark).

The discovery of these species is important because they are actively
involved in the function of a coral reef through their pelagic larval
stages or their nocturnal migrations to the reef. The role these fishes
play in the ecosystem is thus often underestimated.

Visual observations are (still) necessary However, not all species can be recorded equally easily using eDNA, such as wrasses (Labridae) or blennies (Blenniidae). Reference databases cover these species-rich families only partially, Pellissier says. Because of these gaps, a considerable part
of the eDNA found in the water samples has not yet been assigned.

To further develop the approach, the researchers are hard at work
sequencing the DNA of more fish species and feeding the data into the
reference databases.

Nevertheless, dives will still be needed to record some species that are
poorly detected with eDNA, but also to gather supplementary information
such as fish sizes or biomass, which cannot (yet) be recovered from eDNA.

Extraordinary diversity in the Coral Triangle The researchers also
confirmed earlier findings that the composition of species varies widely
among marine bioregions. Fish diversity is exceptionally high in the
"Coral Triangle" between Borneo, Papua New Guinea and the Philippines --
up to five times higher than in the Caribbean, for example. Herbivores (including coral-eating species) are particularly abundant there.

According to Pellissier, this has to do with the fact that throughout
Earth's history, the Coral Triangle was (and still is) very tectonically active, producing a wide range of habitats. The surface temperature of
this marine area was also more stable during the ice ages, which is why
an especially high diversity was able to unfold.

The Caribbean, on the other hand, was more subject to the regime of the
ice ages, and its coral reefs and fish stocks shrank during the cold
periods. In addition, the Isthmus of Panama was formed more than 2.7
million years ago, which, among other things, changed the ocean currents
in the Caribbean. Both events led to higher extinctions.

International cooperation For this study, one sponsor of the research consortium was Monaco Explorations, an organisation of the Prince of
Monaco. The organisation provided the scientists with a research vessel
for the first part of the project, which enabled them to collect water
samples in the Caribbean and off the Colombian coast. More samples were collected on separate trips, also funded by Monaco's government.

"For me as a Swiss researcher, it was enormously important to be part of
an international collaboration," Pellissier says. Without connections to
his French, Colombian, Indonesian and Australian partners, he would not
have been able to carry out this study. He adds: "We can't do isolated
research at this level in Switzerland." Another expedition to collect
water samples is planned for later this year.

This time, the researchers want to sample the tropical waters of the
Indian Ocean between South Africa and the Seychelles. The expedition,
which will complement the sampling conducted in previous years, also
had to be postponed because of the coronavirus.


========================================================================== Story Source: Materials provided by ETH_Zurich. Original written by
Peter Ru"egg. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.


========================================================================== Journal Reference:
1. Laetitia Mathon, Virginie Marques, David Mouillot, Camille Albouy,
Marco
Andrello, Florian Baletaud, Giomar H. Borrero-Pe'rez, Tony
Dejean, Graham J. Edgar, Jonathan Grondin, Pierre-Edouard Guerin,
Re'gis Hocde', Jean- Baptiste Juhel, Kadarusman, Eva Maire, Gael
Mariani, Matthew McLean, Andrea Polanco F., Laurent Pouyaud,
Rick D. Stuart-Smith, Hagi Yulia Sugeha, Alice Valentini,
Laurent Vigliola, Indra B. Vimono, Loi"c Pellissier, Ste'phanie
Manel. Cross-ocean patterns and processes in fish biodiversity on
coral reefs through the lens of eDNA metabarcoding.

Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 2022;
289 (1973) DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2022.0162 ==========================================================================

Link to news story: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2022/04/220421141130.htm

--- up 7 weeks, 3 days, 10 hours, 51 minutes
* Origin: -=> Castle Rock BBS <=- Now Husky HPT Powered! (1:317/3)