Doom-and-gloom climate news may scare but also encourage audiences


Date:
July 7, 2023
Source:
Penn State
Summary:
Researchers investigated how seeing frightening news about climate
change day after day may shape the way people feel about the
phenomenon and how willing they are to take action to address it.


Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIN Email

==========================================================================
FULL STORY ==========================================================================
A team of Penn State researchers investigated how seeing frightening news
about climate change day after day may shape the way people feel about
the phenomenon and how willing they are to take action to address it.

Christofer Skurka, Jessica Myrick and graduate student Yin Yang found
that seeing bad news about climate change can make people more afraid
over time, but it also may encourage audiences to think about what
society can do to address the problem. They published the results of
two separate studies in an article titled "Fanning the flames or burning
out? Testing competing hypotheses about repeated exposure to threatening climate change messages," which appeared in the journal Climatic Change.

"The public is surrounded by media coverage about climate change, and
this messaging tends to be negative in tone, focusing on the threats
that climate change poses to human prosperity and ecological health,"
said Skurka, the paper's lead author and an assistant professor of media studies in the Donald P. Bellisario College of Communications. "We
know from years of research in the field of communication that media
messaging can impact our emotions, our beliefs and, in turn, sometimes
our behavior." The first study involved exposing participants to three
days of negative news stories about climate change. A follow-up study
consisted of participants reading negative news headlines about climate
change in the form of Twitter posts for seven consecutive days.

"We found that three days in a row of reading doom-and-gloom news stories
about climate change was linked to greater fear and less hope, which
can potentially hurt an audience's attitude that they can do anything
to tackle the problem," said Myrick, the Donald P. Bellisario Professor
of Health Communication and co- funded faculty member of the Institutes
of Energy and the Environment.

"However, our follow-up study had people look only at headlines and not
full news stories for a longer period of seven days in a row. In that
study, we found that fear peaked after a few days and then held steady."
The researchers reported that over time, people who repeatedly saw
climate change headlines started to feel like they could do more to
affect change and that the topic of climate change was important.

"You would think that as people are repeatedly exposed to threatening
climate news devoid of solutions content that their efficacy beliefs will decrease over time," Skurka said. "We saw the opposite pattern in our
second study. People's efficacy beliefs increased over time. In other
words, the more exposure people had to these threatening news stories
each day, they were increasingly likely to think that they can make a difference in addressing climate change." Skurka said one possibility
is that as the public copes with unpleasant feelings about the enormous
threat climate change presents, they may convince themselves that they
have control over the situation, which translates into greater efficacy
beliefs that their actions will make a difference.

"Our findings suggest that people have gotten used to doom-and-gloom
reporting around climate change and what may be more important for
motivating them to take action is that they see coverage of it on a
daily basis," Myrick said.

"This is called an agenda-setting effect, where a topic that is covered
more often in the news is then viewed as more important by people
who consume the news." According to Skurka, decades of research in communication and psychology show that under certain circumstances,
fear can be motivating.

"We found that people exposed to the high-threat headlines, which tended
to evoke more fear, generally expressed greater intentions to share
the information than people exposed to the low-threat headlines, which
means there may be an advantage to evoking fear," Skurka said. "However, people's responses over time were essentially the same regardless of
whether they were shown the high-threat or low-threat news headlines. That tells us that when it comes to over-time responses to repeated media
exposure, simply mentioning climate change in the news activates
pre-existing emotions and thoughts associated with climate change."
Myrick added that this does not mean that fear-appeals should be used
for all climate change communication. Instead, the more important factor
may be communicating hope and solutions.

"For communication to be most impactful, people need to feel like
there is still something we can do about it to make a difference,"
Myrick said. "That should hopefully motivate reporters and strategic communicators to include information about solutions to climate change
in their messaging."
* RELATED_TOPICS
o Mind_&_Brain
# Social_Psychology # Racial_Issues # Behavior
o Earth_&_Climate
# Environmental_Awareness # Climate # Global_Warming
o Science_&_Society
# Environmental_Policies # World_Development #
Resource_Shortage
* RELATED_TERMS
o Temperature_record_of_the_past_1000_years o
Global_warming_controversy o Kyoto_Protocol
o Global_climate_model o News_media o
Consensus_of_scientists_regarding_global_warming o
Climate_change_mitigation o Scientific_opinion_on_climate_change

==========================================================================

Print

Email

Share ========================================================================== ****** 1 ****** ***** 2 ***** **** 3 ****
*** 4 *** ** 5 ** Breaking this hour ==========================================================================
* Cystic_Fibrosis:_Lasting_Improvement *
Artificial_Cells_Demonstrate_That_'Life_...

* Advice_to_Limit_High-Fat_Dairy_Foods_Challenged
* First_Snapshots_of_Fermion_Pairs *
Why_No_Kangaroos_in_Bali;_No_Tigers_in_Australia
* New_Route_for_Treating_Cancer:_Chromosomes *
Giant_Stone_Artefacts_Found:_Prehistoric_Tools
* Astonishing_Secrets_of_Tunicate_Origins *
Most_Distant_Active_Supermassive_Black_Hole *
Creative_People_Enjoy_Idle_Time_More_Than_Others

Trending Topics this week ========================================================================== PLANTS_&_ANIMALS Insects_(including_Butterflies) Bacteria
Endangered_Animals EARTH_&_CLIMATE Air_Pollution Environmental_Policy
Ice_Ages FOSSILS_&_RUINS Cultures Early_Climate Human_Evolution


==========================================================================

Strange & Offbeat ========================================================================== PLANTS_&_ANIMALS Why_There_Are_No_Kangaroos_in_Bali_(and_No_Tigers_in_Australia) Number_Cruncher_Calculates_Whether_Whales_Are_Acting_Weirdly Fossils_Reveal_How_Ancient_Birds_Molted_Their_Feathers_--_Which_Could_Help Explain_Why_Ancestors_of_Modern_Birds_Survived_When_All_the_Other_Dinosaurs Died EARTH_&_CLIMATE Turning_Old_Maps_Into_3D_Digital_Models_of_Lost_Neighborhoods Squash_Bugs_Are_Attracted_to_and_Eat_Each_Other's_Poop_to_Stock_Their Microbiome How_Urea_May_Have_Been_the_Gateway_to_Life FOSSILS_&_RUINS Giant_Stone_Artefacts_Found_on_Rare_Ice_Age_Site_in_Kent,_UK Apex_Predator_of_the_Cambrian_Likely_Sought_Soft_Over_Crunchy_Prey Newly_Discovered_Jurassic_Fossils_in_Texas Story Source: Materials
provided by Penn_State. Original written by Kevin Sliman. Note: Content
may be edited for style and length.


========================================================================== Journal Reference:
1. Skurka, C., Myrick, J.G. & Yang, Y. Fanning the flames or burning
out?
Testing competing hypotheses about repeated exposure to
threatening climate change messages. Climatic Change, 2023 DOI:
10.1007/s10584-023- 03539-8 ==========================================================================

Link to news story: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2023/07/230707153841.htm

--- up 1 year, 18 weeks, 4 days, 10 hours, 50 minutes
* Origin: -=> Castle Rock BBS <=- Now Husky HPT Powered! (1:317/3)